Carrie Underwood Faces Backlash After Comments to Jamal Roberts on ‘American Idol’

Carrie Underwood is under fire after her remarks to fan-favorite Jamal Roberts during Monday night’s Disney-themed episode of American Idol, with many viewers accusing the judge of showing favoritism — and possibly undermining the competition’s last Black finalist.

What Sparked the Outrage?
Roberts delivered a powerful rendition of “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough,” drawing roaring applause and standing ovations from both Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie. But Underwood’s critique caught fans off guard:

“You missed a big opportunity to work the stage and entertain… We’re getting close to the finale. It’s time to go all out.”

While Richie called the performance “incredible” and praised Jamal’s ability to “make any song his own,” Carrie remained seated during the ovation — a move that didn’t go unnoticed.

Social Media Reactions
The response online was swift and passionate:

• Double Standards: “So Jamal gets told to move more, but the others just stand there and get praised?” asked @lakenbriannaxo.
• Bias Accusations: Some fans saw a pattern. “Carrie CLEARLY doesn’t care for Jamal,” posted @LadyKaija. Others chimed in with claims that she favors country singers and overlooks soul artists.
• Praise for Roberts: “He doesn’t need to dance around — his voice carries everything,” tweeted @ButtaKupJ. “That was raw talent. Pure soul.”

Redemption Through Music
Later in the episode, Roberts returned with an emotional take on “Beauty and the Beast,” once again wowing the crowd. This time, Underwood offered only minimal feedback, while the other judges doubled down on their support.

Luke Bryan sealed the moment with a rallying cry:

“Let’s win this thing, baby!”

Looking Ahead
Despite the controversy, Roberts secured his place in the Top 3 and will perform in the Season 23 finale this Sunday. But Carrie’s criticism has left a bitter taste for some viewers — with a growing chorus online suggesting she be replaced next season.